Fangirly Investigates: Can There Be a Perfect Series Finale?

fans-are-not-happy-with-the-how-i-met-your-mother-series-finaleSeriously, is it even possible?

Last night, 9 seasons of How I Met Your Mother culminated in an hour long series finale.  The episode began with Ted Mosby still never having even laid eyes on the titular mother, so I went into already concerned.  How were they going to give me all of the moments that I wanted to see between Ted and the mother?  It just wasn’t possible.

SPOILERS FOLLOW: My worst fears were realized.

Bummer #1) After a season of Barney and Robin’s wedding, we find out that 3 years later they got a divorce.

Bummer #2) Robin gets too preoccupied with her job and basically never sees the gang anymore, breaking Lily’s heart (and mine).

Bummer #3) The mother dies.  Yeah, you read that right.  On a show called How I Met Your freaking Mother, the mother dies.

Bummer #4) After sitting through 9 seasons worth of story telling, Ted’s kids tell him that it is so obvious why he has been telling them all these stories.  It has not been to tell them how he met their mother, but how he may still have feelings for their “Aunt Robin”.  This was mainly a bummer because I never really “got” Ted and Robin.

Last Forever Part OneWhilst I am beginning to come around to the finale a little bit more, I was initially crushed.  This entire show has been building up to Ted meeting his soul mate, the one.  Or at least that is what I thought.

I have to at least respect that they hoodwinked all of us, because, yes, in theory it makes sense that this has been leading up to Ted ending up with Robin seeing as how the show has mainly centered on their on again, off again thing.


Mainly, the finale got me thinking about series finales in general.  Has there ever been one that has been universally adored?  In short, no.

I have to imagine that this is in part due to the fact that when you build a relationship, whether in real life or with a TV show (personally, my favorite kind of relationship), and you loved that person/show, the goodbye is always going to be the hardest part.

That is why I am trying to look on the HIMYM finale with some optimism and instead think of all the good times we had.   And not that I wanted to throw my TV out the window over this crushing major disappointment (*salute* Major Disappointment.)


7 thoughts on “Fangirly Investigates: Can There Be a Perfect Series Finale?

  1. First of all, I *salute* Major Disappointment. Haha, thank you for ending it with that little gem. Okay, so I literally watched it an hour ago. At school. Sobbing. I love this series so much. I loved when Barney met his baby girl (sob #1). I loved when Robin showed up at the McLaren’s right before the wedding, but loved even more when Tracy walked in through the door in her wedding dress and Ted was speechless. They are perfect together! I actually always understood the Ted/Robin relationship, and i love them together. However, I feel like once Barney and Robin got engaged she changed into an even colder, less loveable Robin than before. She almost became the girl version of Barney (besides the sleeping with everyone part). So my problem with them ending up together is that she isn’t the same Robin Ted fell in love with and I don’t think she’ll be the right wife for him/step mom for the kids. Although even still, I was actually decently satisfied with the ending, once I came to terms with his wife’s devastating death. Ugh. I guess I have mixed feelings. I’m still really emotional.

    • I agree with the Robin not being the same Robin that Ted fell in love with, because that Robin wouldn’t have abandoned the gang like that. Also, she has FIVE dogs but she can’t make it work with Barney?! No sense. But I loved all the little callbacks to jokes and such and all of it felt real to me, but there was a lot to bum me out, as well. I don’t know. I’m very conflicted.

  2. I hated this ending so much! One of the things I think was wrong was over the last 3-4 seasons Ted has fallen out of love with Robin. She wasn’t the one and he knew it. He still loved her because he never found someone to make him forget her! Hell, we even had an episode this season about him letting her go. Robin has always been too selfish and too self absorbed for Ted. Once he found Tracy there is no way he would ever look back and long for Robin, especially after 10+ years of her being out of the picture. It was like they ignored all the growth Ted did over the last few seasons and even into the future. And since when did robin come back into the picture. They see here like once every 3 years and then the kids are like we love aunt Robin, ya cause they’ve seen her 5 times in their lives they love her.

    My biggest pet peeve is Ted and Tracy had real chemistry, I wanted to watch them, Ted and Robin haven’t had real chemistry since season 2. If Robin couldn’t give up her crazy lifestyle for Barney what makes it so she will for Ted and knowing that why would he go after her.

    • But I know that there were people that also were unhappy with how that one went down.

      Also, I don’t know who you are, “Anonymous”, but I am guessing you are one of the people who has been berating me to watch Breaking Bad. I feel like that is a pretty safe guess.

  3. Amen to everything that was said about Tracy dying off and Ted and Robin ending up together! Some other things to consider:

    (1) After the series finale, it seems like Season 9 was completely disconnected with the rest of the series and finale. One of my biggest complaints about Season 9 was that the show tried to change Barney’s nature into something he wasn’t so he and Robin would make sense. I.e., he was actually this “good guy” (minus sleeping with everyone) who took down the evil corporate world and was going to settle down with Robin, to only find out both he and Robin only lasted three years!
    (2) Also, did anyone else feel like Lily and Marshall were kind of missing from the finale? Especially Marshall who just didn’t seem to get a lot of air time or seemed out of character.
    (3) And what was with Ted taking 7 years to get married! That was so unlike Ted.

    After watching a second time I started to feel a little better about this ending. I do not know why anyone cried, even the Barney scene. But here is what I got from it, that life has this funny way of changing you in ways you do not expect, even the closet group of friends. That’s it. Ted meeting the mother was just a red herring.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s